If you’ve ever browsed a Commander deck list online and balked at the price tags, you’re not alone. Cards like Dockside Extortionist, Mana Crypt, or Gaea’s Cradle regularly cost over $100—each.
But here’s the good news: in casual EDH circles, proxy cards offer a fun, fair, and wallet-friendly way to enjoy Magic to its fullest. This article is your complete guide to using proxies in Commander—from “Are MTG proxies legal?” to how to use them respectfully in your group.
🤔 Are MTG Proxies Legal?
Let’s clarify: proxies are not legal in sanctioned tournaments. Events governed by the DCI or WPN, such as Friday Night Magic, Regional Qualifiers, or official Commander tournaments, require real Magic cards.
However, in casual playgroups, proxies are 100% legal—if your group agrees to them.
✅ TL;DR: Proxies are fine in casual Commander. Just get group consensus.
💬 Understanding Casual Proxy Rules
Unlike tournament formats, Commander is built on social contracts and house rules. This means proxy use is largely guided by mutual understanding.
Here are common casual proxy rules most EDH pods follow:
- Use proxies for price accessibility – Cards like Dual Lands, Fetches, or Mana Drain can be proxied to level the playing field.
- No “proxy advantage” – Don’t use proxies to play a $15,000 deck while everyone else runs precons. Match power levels respectfully.
- Limit proxies in high-powered pods – Some groups cap proxies to 5–10 per deck.
- Keep your proxies readable and sleeve-friendly – Avoid blurry printouts or confusing stand-ins.
If you’re new to proxies or Commander in general, check out the official Commander Rules Committee site for insights on gameplay philosophy and table etiquette.
👥 Commander Proxy Etiquette 101
Using proxies is as much about respect as it is about budget. Here are some best practices for smooth gameplay:
1. Announce proxy use before the game
Be upfront: “Hey, I’m using 7 proxies in this deck—mostly lands and one tutor.”
2. Keep your proxies clean and legible
No sticky notes or worn paper cutouts. Use quality printed proxies like those from Abyss Proxy Shop that match sleeve feel and card clarity.
3. Only proxy what you intend to eventually own—or test
Proxies should support deck testing, budget builds, or style—avoid proxying entire decks without real cards unless your group is on board.
4. Offer to swap out proxies if they bother anyone
Good table vibes > shiny cards. Be flexible.
🧰 Where to Get Beginner-Friendly MTG Proxies
Abyss Proxy Shop offers beginner proxy bundles curated for casual Commander players. These include:
- Staple proxy kits for cards like Rhystic Study, Cyclonic Rift, Fierce Guardianship, and Dockside Extortionist
- Land bundles for players building mana bases affordably (Shocklands, Fetches, Duals)
- Theme packs like Artifact Combo, Green Ramp, and Tribal Lords
All cards are printed with premium card stock and crisp detail, offering realistic feel, accurate sizing, and shuffle durability—especially when sleeved.
👉 Check out our beginner-friendly Commander Proxy Bundles at Abyss Proxy Shop
🎯 Why Casual Commander is Perfect for Proxies
Commander’s heart lies in fun, variety, and accessibility. While some decks run $3,000 price tags, many amazing decks can be built for under $100—with proxies filling in the “unobtainable” slots.
Proxies support:
- 💰 Budget-conscious players
- 🧪 Playtesters exploring new builds
- 🎨 Custom aesthetics and alt-art cards
- 👨👩👧👦 Inclusive gameplay for new players or younger fans
📚 FAQs: Commander Proxy Edition
❓ Can I use proxies in a precon upgrade?
Absolutely! Proxying a few high-value staples makes precons more competitive while staying budget-friendly.
❓ What counts as a proxy?
Any non-official card used in place of a real MTG card. This includes printed proxies, handwritten stand-ins, or altered cards.
❓ Where can I find high-quality proxies?
Abyss Proxy Shop offers high-grade, beginner-friendly proxy bundles with realistic feel and visual accuracy.
🧭 Final Thoughts
So—are MTG proxies legal? Officially, no. But in casual Commander playgroups, the answer is: yes, absolutely—with the right etiquette.
Whether you’re upgrading a precon, building a budget powerhouse, or exploring new archetypes, proxies open the door to creativity, competition, and community fun—without breaking the bank.
Browse our curated Commander proxy bundles at Abyss Proxy Shop and upgrade your deck, your way.