With the rising cost of Magic: The Gathering cards, more and more players are turning to proxies—high-quality substitutes for expensive or hard-to-find cards. Whether you’re looking to build a cEDH deck, test new strategies, or just play with your friends, proxies are becoming an essential part of the MTG experience.
But one major question remains: Are MTG proxies legal in 2025? In this article, we break down the legality, rules, and best practices around proxies so you can make informed decisions and enjoy the game without breaking the bank.
What Are MTG Proxies?
MTG proxies are non-official versions of Magic: The Gathering cards. They can be handmade, printed at home, or ordered from proxy shops. Players use them for many reasons:
- Replacing expensive staples (e.g., Black Lotus, Gaea’s Cradle)
- Testing new decks before buying the real cards
- Playing cards they own digitally or can’t access physically
- Avoiding damage to rare or foil cards
High-quality proxies are printed to closely resemble the original cards, and when sleeved with real Magic cards, they’re virtually indistinguishable during play.
Are MTG Proxies Legal for Tournaments?
The short answer: No, proxies are not legal in sanctioned tournaments.
Wizards of the Coast (WotC), the publisher of Magic: The Gathering, does not allow proxy cards in official events. That includes:
- Friday Night Magic (FNM)
- Regional Championships
- Grand Prix or Pro Tours
- Any sanctioned tournament using Wizards EventLink or Judge Tower
In sanctioned play, only official, unaltered Magic cards are permitted. The only exception is when a judge creates a temporary proxy due to a damaged card during the event, and that’s strictly regulated.
Are Proxies Allowed in Casual Play?
Yes! Proxies are widely accepted in casual and Commander playgroups.
In 2025, the Commander community continues to embrace proxies, especially as card prices rise. Many cEDH pods and kitchen table groups not only allow proxies—they encourage them to make the game more accessible and inclusive.
If you’re playing at home, at your LGS (local game store), or in a proxy-friendly online group, proxies are fair game. Just make sure to:
- Communicate with your group before playing
- Use high-quality proxies for clarity and consistency
- Avoid using proxies to gain unfair advantages (like intentionally misrepresenting a card)
Wizards of the Coast’s Stance on Proxies (2025 Update)
Wizards has not changed its official stance in 2025: proxies are not allowed in sanctioned play, and unofficial cards may not be sold or represented as genuine.
That said, the explosion of digital play, custom cube formats, and community-led events has created a gray area. WotC doesn’t typically crack down on proxy use in non-commercial, casual settings.
However, be careful: selling proxies branded or designed to look exactly like real cards without disclaimers can violate copyright law. Always label your cards as proxies, and avoid using them in for-profit, unsanctioned tournaments unless the host approves.
When Are Proxies Most Useful?
Proxies are invaluable in these scenarios:
- Budget cEDH decks: Compete without paying $1,000+ for a deck
- Playtesting: Try new cards before buying them
- Protecting valuable cards: Keep your foils and rares safe at home
- Custom formats: Print unique cards for cubes, chaos drafts, or alternate game modes
They’re also a great way for new players to jump in without being limited by card availability.
Best Practices for Using Proxies in 2025
To avoid confusion or negative experiences, follow these best practices:
- Be Transparent – Always tell your playgroup or LGS that you’re using proxies.
- Use Quality Prints – Blurry or incorrect proxies can cause confusion. High-resolution, accurate proxies help maintain game integrity.
- Label Clearly – Consider writing “proxy” on the bottom corner or back to avoid misrepresentation.
- Respect the Space – Some LGSs or organizers may not allow proxies, even for casual events. Always ask first.
Final Thoughts
So, are MTG proxies legal in 2025? Legally, you can’t use them in official Wizards tournaments, and selling them commercially comes with risks. But in casual and community-driven play, proxies are more accepted than ever—especially in formats like Commander and cEDH where creativity and accessibility thrive.
At the end of the day, Magic is about fun, connection, and creativity. Proxies help keep the game inclusive and exciting, especially for those who want to compete without spending a fortune. Just be open, be respectful, and keep casting those big spells—proxies or not.
Need high-quality MTG proxies for your next deck? Check out our latest collections at AbyssProxyShop.com and bring your dream deck to life—without breaking the bank.