Using proxies in Magic: The Gathering playgroup—especially in Commander—has become more common than ever. But before you shuffle up that proxy-filled deck and sit down at the table, there’s one important thing to do:
Talk to your playgroup.
Here’s how to approach the conversation, what to say, and how to make sure everyone at the table is on the same page.
1. Understand Why People Use Proxies
Before you talk, know your reasons. Most MTG players use proxies to:
- Afford expensive staples like Gaea’s Cradle or Mana Crypt
- Test new decks before buying real cards
- Customize decks with full-art or alternate-art versions
- Replace damaged or unavailable cards
If you’re clear on why you proxy, it’s easier to explain it to others.
2. Choose the Right Setting
Bring it up before game night or during a casual conversation—not right as you reveal a hand full of $1,000 proxies.
You might say:
“Hey, I’ve been brewing some new Commander decks with proxies for testing. Are you cool with me bringing one next game night?”
3. Acknowledge Other Players’ Concerns
Some players worry that proxies:
- Give an unfair power advantage
- Devalue their collection
- Break immersion if poorly made
Listen. Be respectful. Acknowledge their concerns. Then calmly explain how proxies don’t replace real cards—they just make the game more accessible and keep brewing fun.
4. Be Transparent About What’s Proxied
Make it clear which cards are proxies before the game starts. Some players are fine with a few, but might not enjoy a full 100-card proxy list.
You can say:
“This deck has about 10 proxies—mostly lands and one or two pricey staples I want to test.”
Transparency builds trust.
5. Use High-Quality Proxies
The better your proxies look and feel, the more accepted they’ll be.
- Sharp text and art
- Accurate sizing
- Sleeved and indistinguishable during play
Low-effort, blurry printouts taped to lands won’t win anyone over. That’s where Abyss Proxy Shop comes in.
6. Offer Alternatives if Needed
If someone in your group is uncomfortable, offer to swap out the proxies for basics or play a different deck.
You might say:
“No worries—I brought another deck without proxies just in case.”
It’s not about “winning the argument.” It’s about keeping the game fun for everyone.
7. Proxies Can Help the Whole Group
Remind them: proxies aren’t just for you.
- Help newer players build decks
- Level the power between budget and bling decks
- Encourage creativity and experimentation
A table full of proxies often leads to better, more exciting games.
Final Word: Communication First, Proxies Second
Using proxies should never surprise or frustrate your playgroup. If you’re upfront, respectful, and playing for the right reasons, most groups will welcome proxies as a way to make Magic more fun and accessible.
When you’re ready to upgrade your proxy game, check out AbyssProxyShop.com for premium-quality proxies that are beautiful, functional, and affordable.
Next Blog Ideas:
- Commander Deck Tech: Budget cEDH With Proxies
- Are MTG Proxies Legal? What You Should Know in 2025
- Top 5 Commander Staples Worth Proxing Right Now
Want one of these next, or something different?