With the rise of MTG proxy cards, players are asking: What separates a good proxy card from a bad one? Whether you’re upgrading your Commander deck or just want to test a build before buying real cards, understanding the key traits of high-quality MTG proxies will make all the difference.
Here’s what to look for when choosing or printing the perfect MTG proxy.
1. Accurate Sizing & Thickness
A high-quality proxy must match the dimensions and feel of a real MTG card.
- Standard Size: 2.5″ x 3.5″
- Cardstock: Look for sturdy stock with a professional feel—not flimsy paper or obvious fakes.
Why it matters: Proxies that feel “off” in a sleeve can be distracting or suspicious at the table.
2. Sharp, Legible Text
Proxies should have crisp, clear rules text that mirrors the original card.
- No typos
- Proper font and spacing
- Accurate oracle text
Bonus Tip: Include a subtle watermark or symbol to differentiate it from a real card without hurting the aesthetic.
3. High-Resolution Artwork
Art is where many proxies shine—even beyond the originals.
- Full-art proxies are popular for their stunning visual appeal.
- Alternate art can bring new life to old staples.
- Avoid pixelated or stretched images.
Why it matters: MTG is a visual game. Quality art = better immersion and more compliments from fellow players.
4. True-to-Color Borders and Frames
A good proxy should use accurate border colors and layouts to signal its card type instantly (land, instant, creature, etc.).
- Color identity matters for Commander legality.
- Vintage vs. modern frames can change a card’s vibe entirely.
5. Reliable Card Back or Double-Sleeve Compatibility
While many proxies use a slightly altered or custom back:
- Make sure it’s not obviously fake when double-sleeved.
- Transparent sleeves or inner sleeves help hide minor differences.
Pro Tip: Most playgroups are okay with proxies—but still, make them clean and consistent.
6. Balanced Between Aesthetic and Playability
The best proxies strike a perfect balance:
- Beautiful to look at
- Functional during play
- Easy to shuffle and handle
- Recognizable at a glance
7. Ethically Used
Good proxy use is honest and respectful:
- Use them in casual or agreed-upon settings.
- Don’t try to sell them as real cards.
- Support artists and vendors who respect the MTG community.
Why Buy Proxies from Abyss Proxy Shop?
At AbyssProxyShop.com, we believe that high-quality proxies aren’t just stand-ins—they’re upgrades. You get:
- Crisp, premium card stock
- Custom art options
- Competitive pricing
- Cards tested and loved by real MTG players
Whether you’re brewing your dream Commander deck or building on a budget, we’ve got the perfect proxies for you.
Final Thought:
A good proxy doesn’t just look the part—it feels like part of your deck. When you play with proxies from Abyss Proxy Shop, you’re not cutting corners. You’re choosing quality, customization, and creativity.
Would you like blog #7? Possible next topics:
- How to Talk to Your Playgroup About Using Proxies
- Commander Deck Tech: Proxy Build for Competitive Play
- The Legality of MTG Proxies: What You Should Know
Let me know which you’d like next!