Commander (EDH) continues to dominate Magic: The Gathering in 2025—and with it, the cost of building a powerful deck keeps rising. That’s why more players are turning to MTG proxies to play top-tier decks without draining their bank accounts.
So which cards are everyone proxying this year?
Here are the 10 most popular proxy cards among EDH players in 2025—and why they’re worth adding to your deck.
1. Dockside Extortionist
- Why It’s Popular: Generates absurd value in token or artifact-based decks.
- Real Card Price: Over $70
- Proxy Tip: Get one with alternate pirate-themed art for flavor.
2. Mana Crypt
- Why It’s Popular: Free mana = explosive starts.
- Real Card Price: $150+
- Proxy Tip: Look for proxies with old-border or full-art variants.
3. Jeweled Lotus
- Why It’s Popular: Turbo out your commander by turn one.
- Real Card Price: $80+
- Proxy Tip: A foil-look proxy with dark, gothic art is a fan favorite.
4. Fierce Guardianship
- Why It’s Popular: Protect your commander for free—perfect for cEDH or casual.
- Real Card Price: $60+
- Proxy Tip: Customize with a Planeswalker-themed backdrop for personality.
5. Gaea’s Cradle
- Why It’s Popular: Turns go-wide strategies into mana powerhouses.
- Real Card Price: $800+
- Proxy Tip: Many love stylized proxies featuring Elvish or forest art.
6. Vampiric Tutor
- Why It’s Popular: Instant-speed tutor for anything.
- Real Card Price: $50–$70
- Proxy Tip: Choose proxies with old-school black borders for that OG look.
7. Imperial Seal
- Why It’s Popular: Tutors just like Vampiric—but even pricier.
- Real Card Price: $200+
- Proxy Tip: A clean, minimalistic proxy lets the power speak for itself.
8. Rhystic Study
- Why It’s Popular: Draw engine disguised as an annoying question.
- Real Card Price: $40–$60
- Proxy Tip: Some players love anime-style proxies for this one.
9. The Tabernacle at Pendrell Vale
- Why It’s Popular: Control card that shuts down token decks.
- Real Card Price: $4,000+
- Proxy Tip: You’ll only find this in proxy form for 99% of players—so make it shine.
10. Dual Lands (OG ABUR)
- Why They’re Popular: No downside fixing for 2+ color decks.
- Real Card Price: $300–$1000 each
- Proxy Tip: Proxy full cycles (like Underground Sea or Volcanic Island) to match your deck’s colors and keep land bases consistent.
Bonus: Why Proxy These Cards in 2025?
- Affordability: Many of these cards are out of print and skyrocketing in price.
- Accessibility: Not everyone has access to a Black Lotus—but proxies level the field.
- Deck Customization: Get the cards and the art you want.
How to Get Your Own Proxies
Ready to add these all-stars to your Commander deck?
Visit Abyss Proxy Shop for:
- High-quality card stock
- Stunning art options
- Affordable pricing
- Fast turnaround for your next game night
Final Thought:
You don’t have to spend thousands to play like a pro. Proxy the best, play your best, and enjoy Magic the way it was meant to be played—with fun, fairness, and your personal flair.